The DePaula Difference

DePaula Jewelers & Islamorada Jewelers

DePaula has been the most trusted name in jewelry in the Florida Keys for over thirty-five years. We carefully curate our selection of nautical jewelry, classic pieces, and sport watches to showcase the Island Lifestyle of our hometown. Our Fish Hook and Treasure Coin jewelry is handcrafted, and we offer custom jewelry services to any clients that may want something entirely unique. We have shops open in Islamorada and Tavernier, Florida. We offer a wide selection of our pieces here at

Family-Owned Business

serving the Florida Keys and living the Island Life for over 30 years

Graduate Gemologists

GIA-certified: the most prestigious credential in the industry

Master Jeweler

Joe DePaula has handcrafted custom jewelry pieces for over 40 years

Buy with Confidence from

DePaula Jewelers has been in business for over 35 years, and we have operated an online boutique for over a decade. We are members of both JA, the Jewelers of America, and BBB, the Better Business Bureau. We have been IJO (Independent Jewelers Organization) Master Jewelers for twenty years. There are two GIA-certified Graduate Gemologists on staff, as well as a Jeweler with over 40 years experience in the industry. We are also members of the National Association of Jewelry Appraisers.

We operate two brick-and-mortar stores, so you can buy local online. Each piece of jewelry in our stores is hand-selected, and our custom pieces are handcrafted here in the Florida Keys. We want to make your experience here at as smooth and engaging as possible, so please contact us us with any questions you may have.

(0) Items
Items 0
Subtotal $ 0.00
To Top